Woman making a gross face.

10 Weirdest (and Creepy) Thrift Store Donations Workers Have Encountered

Have you ever thought about how thrift store goods have been carefully picked over so you don’t stumble upon a repulsive donation? Thrift store workers open up about the strangest items they’ve encountered.

Note: Some quotes in this piece have been lightly edited for grammar.

1: The Worst Stain

Photo Credit: kvladimirv via stock.adobe.com.

A brand new thrift store volunteer was advised by the person training them they should wear gloves. They declined, citing latex making them sweat. Their tune soon changed when they began going through two garbage bags that a “flustered” elderly woman had left earlier that day.

The woman insisted she didn’t want to fill out a tax deduction form because “her husband recently passed, and she wanted to get rid of his things.” The volunteer soon realized why the woman was in a hurry. With their bare hands, they pulled out a massive, used piece of underwear boasting a huge poop stain.

2: Creepy to the Extreme

Scary doll
Photo Credit: frenta via stock.adobe.com.

A thrift store employee remembers chatting with the woman in charge of antiques about a “creepy doll with staring glass eyes.” The even more spine-chilling part? She told them the doll had real human hair and human teeth. The antique worker informed them the doll “was from the 1800s and the teeth were likely the child’s baby teeth that had fallen out.”

3: Can It Get Any Bigger?

Garbage can.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

“An industrial-sized trash bag of unwrapped, but unused, individual tampons” was the weirdest donation one thrift store employee ever encountered. A commenter ventured that perhaps someone was smuggling goods in the tampon wrappers and boxes.

4: Oh, Ho Ho

Santa Claus holding a list.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

Little did a devotee working at a church yard sale know they were in for a rude awakening that day. “Someone donated a used his and hers matching Santa & Mrs. Claus lingerie set.” Now that’s a merry Christmas.

5: Fine Wine?

Person looking surprised.
Photo Credit: master1305 via stock.adobe.com.

A thrift store employee remembers their store received a bottle of “finely aged” pee in a wine bottle. The donation center employee was new and forgot they shouldn’t throw bodily fluids into the trash compactor. The store had “basically no airflow” and it smelled like pee for days.

6: Secure Storage

Photo Credit: Dmitry via stock.adobe.com.

One thrift store worker remembers finding a firearm inside of a computer. Another joked they “must’ve downloaded it off the deep web.”

7: The Wrong Rattle

Woman with hand on her forehead.
Photo Credit: kues1 via stock.adobe.com.

A commenter tells the story of their friend encountering a bottle adorned with painted twine. The man, already confused by the bottle, was surprised to hear it rattle when he moved it. What was waiting for him when he opened it, you ask? “Ashes and bone fragments.”

8: Full Figurines

Couple on a motorcycle.
Photo Credit: deagreez via stock.adobe.com.

One thrift store worker lists several repulsive items they encountered in donation boxes that we’ll mostly leave to your imagination. But one that stood out (or up?) among the rest was a box full of stone figurines of the male body part.

9: Digging Carefully

Person looking scared.
Photo Credit: deagreez via stock.adobe.com.

A former Goodwill employee remembers going through a bag of donated clothes and having a startling encounter. “I pulled out a shirt, and multiple razor blades came out with it.” Their guess was someone had done it on purpose.

10: Birthday Suit

Row of birthday candles.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

The friend of a thrift store manager says they’ve heard many stories of weird items people donate through the years. Among their favorites? A Halloween costume designed to be the “birthday suit” of an elderly woman, complete with hair down there.

Generosity for Thought

Man making a disgusted face.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

Cat pee on clothes doesn’t fall under the “weird” category per se. However, a former thrift store worker urges people to be mindful when choosing what to donate. “If something was found with cat urine on it, the entire pile and anything near it got thrown away.”

What’s With Urns?

Sad face.
Photo Credit: robsonphoto via stock.adobe.com.

Many current and former thrift store workers commented on an all-too-common item in donation boxes: Urns. One church yardsale volunteer even remembered a student encountering dozens of framed pictures of an elderly woman, “commenting on how sad [that] someone must not have cared to keep pictures of their grandma. ” The next bag contained an urn full of ashes.

Source: Reddit.

The Thrift Store Making Big Money From Your Luggage

A bag with a "Lost" tag on it.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

Do you know what happens when airlines can’t reunite lost suitcases with their owners? Unclaimed Baggage is the only lost luggage thrift store in the US. They’ve had some unique (and living) finds.

The Thrift Store Making Big Money From Your Lost Luggage

A 1970s Lesson for Younger Generations

Woman from the 1970s.
Photo Credit: Alexander Wurditsch via stock.adobe.com. 

People often remember the 70s through the lens of groovy music and bell-bottom jeans. But it was also a decade defined by soaring inflation, political upheaval, and, apparently, a lot of shag carpets. Folks who lived through the 1970s shared what it was really like in an online forum. 

People Who Lived Through the 1970s Let Younger Generations in on What It Was Like

Worst TV Programs of the 60s, 70s, and 80s

60s tv show.
Photo Credit: lunamarina via stock.adobe.com. 

Quick: What are your least favorite TV shows from the 60s, 70s, and 80s? TV lovers share their thoughts.

Worst TV Programs of the 60s, 70s, and 80s, According to People Who Grew Up With Them

15 Things People Miss About the 90s and 2000s

Woman dancing.
Photo Credit: deagreez via stock.adobe.com.

Looking for a blast from the past? From low-rise jeans to the all too familiar noise of dial-up internet, there’s a lot to be nostalgic about from the 90s and 2000s. 

15 Things People Miss About the 90s and 2000s

25 Most Expensive American Cities

A fork through two 50 dollar bills.
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

Living in America isn’t cheap, but the cost of living in some cities is downright outrageous. The rankings are about as blue as each state’s political makeup.

25 Most Expensive Cities in America Breaking Bank Accounts

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top